HISTORY
FORWARD TO THE ORIGINAL PUBLICATION
I would like to think that this book is finished now-but having lived with it and the lives which populate it for over a decade, I know it isn’t, just as the repercussions of the war in Vietnam will continue to reverberate through our thoughts, feelings, and actions for decades to come.
I did not make this story, It came that way, ready-made, defined by historical circumstances, generated by the soldiers who have had to fight the most insidious and intimate battle the one with yourself. That battle, which has become part of a new consciousness in the American mind, has-one hopes-just commenced. Indeed, the lessons for us to learn are not on the vacant battlefields of South Vietnam or Cambodia not within the reams of statistical data being gathered even now by analysts in the Pentagon who ask: What happened? How? Why? not gained by staring at graduation pictures, rereading letters, or standing solemnly before headstones the lessons are within us the living . . . if we would only look.
But who wants to look back at, to understand, to share responsibility for a war so botched, so contradictory, so riddled with accusations as this one? Who wants to revive a period in American history when fathers stood against sons, brothers against brothers, men against themselves? But we must try, lest the tragedy of Vietnam be repeated tomorrow, or the day after.
In writing this book, I am mainly a chronicler who was left no choice but to try to speak for the inarticulate, the psychically scarred, and the wasted. This book, therefore, is neither a defense nor a prosecution of the events which occurred in Vietnam. Rather it is a synthesis of personal experiences, observations, interviews, and journals here woven together into a narrative which, I trust, will be accepted with compassion, will be understood and heeded because these men are your own.
Charles Coleman
New Bedford, Massachusetts
July, 1979
THE MAKING OF SERGEANT BACK AGAIN: THE ANTHOLOGY OF CRITICAL AND CLINICAL COMMENTARY
PTSD was brand new on the diagnostic scene (DSM-III) at about the same time that Sergeant Back Again was published in 1980, and the diagnosis was really predicated on the symptoms displayed by some of the 9 million individuals who served during the Vietnam War Era, approximately 2.7 of whom returned home from active in-country combat tours of which over 300,000 were wounded and 58,220 never returned alive. Of the 2.7 million who did survive and returned state-side, estimates suggest that approximately 16% of the males and 8.75% of the females suffered from PTSD upon-or soon after-their return, with a subsequent, post-separation longitudinal study (NVVRS) indicating that about 30% of all veterans experienced PTSD at some point in their lifetime.
By 2000-25 years after the fall of Saigon and 20 years post-publication of Sergeant-PTSD was close to becoming a “household” initialism having been “passed on” from predominately a” disorder of combat vets” (e.g. Rambo, Apocalypse Now, Sergeant Back Again) to the greater population of first responders and on into the general population of everyday civilians who experience some sort of (psychological) traumatic stress whether in-person, observed or imagined. That’s a far cry-literally-from the post-war symptoms of veterans and civilians of any wartime conflict.
PTSD is not really new. It’s been described in hundreds of thousands of letters, poems, novels, paintings, plays, movies, and songs-even as far back as the Greek historian, Herodotus, who described the exact same symptoms of PTSD in his observations and commentary of the Battle of Marathon (490 BCE) and a soldier, Epizelus, who “suffered sudden, permanent hysterical blindness after witnessing a terrifying vision of a giant warrior slaying the man beside him, despite sustaining no physical wounds” himself. This “accounting” is strikingly similar to what “Danny Two” experiences in his own “accounting” his “blindness” caused by what he witnessed during the Pinkville Massacre resulting in his later shooting himself through his right eye in The Gentling of Hanna Johansen: A Betrayal of Trust).
Sergeant Back Again: The Anthology of Critical and Clinical Commentary was published by PTSD Press in 2010 with the express purpose of putting “PTSD of the 1980’s” into contemporary context, in part because not only had the clinical diagnoses and categorical classification morphed, but a new breed of victim-survivors was emerging to join the ranks of victim-survivors of wartime atrocities beginning with the so-called Texas Tower Massacre(1966) where 14 people gunned down by ex-Marine Charles Whitman on the campus of the UT-Austin followed by the Columbine High School Massacre (1999) of 12 students and 1 teacher by Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold followed by Seung-Hui Cho who massacred 32 people on the campus of Virginia Tech (2007) followed by….
The point being that a new kind of “domestic terrorism” was (is) contributing a yet another “cause” of PTSD which is only now being fully realized as a traumatic stressor at a national level. But the origins of PTSD, historically, have been with us, as a species, in earlier forms when they were not yet recognized as symptoms of PTSD including, for example, in the character of Nick Adams in Hemingway’s short story, “A Way You’ll Never Be,” and in the works of Robert Graves as critiqued in Dr. John Presley’s brilliant historical perspective entitled “Neurasthenia and the Cure of Literature: Robert Graves, Siegfried Sassoon, Andy Collins,” and in Dr. Philip Beidler’s comprehensive Itinerary “Introduction” to Sergeant Back Again “THE VIETNAM WAR NOVEL THAT MADE PTSD REAL!”
John Presley, Ph.D.
John Presley is Professor of English at Illinois State University, teaching in ISU’s doctoral programs in higher education administration and is Editor of /Planning and Changing. / He was Provost at ISU, 2003-2008, and previously served as chief academic officer or as dean at four universities, including Lafayette College and the University of Michigan.
A frequent contributor in the fields of modern literature, education, and civic engagement, Presley serves on AASCU’s National Implementation Committee for the American Democracy Project. His most recent publication is /The Future of Higher Education: Perspectives from America’s Academic Leaders/ (with Gary Olson) for Paradigm Press. He is currently editing Robert Graves’s /The Nazarene Gospel Restored/ for Carcanet Press. Presley is co-editing a volume on university students and political engagement which is forthcoming from the American Association of State Colleges and Universities.
Historical Perspective:
Preludes to PTSD
Neurasthenia and the Cure of Literature:
Robert Graves, Siegfried Sassoon, Andy Collins
By John Woodrow Presley, Ph.D.
Neurasthenia as a diagnosis of “nerve weakness” is a historical precursor for the diagnostic terms that were used for World Wars I (shell-shock) and II (combat fatigue), and on into the Vietnam War (post-traumatic stress disorder) era. From the earliest days of WWI even to the present, writers have dealt with such diagnoses for their literary characters in fiction and poetry, and for themselves in memoir. In fact, in the case of Andy Collins, the main character in Charles Coleman’s Sergeant Back Again, the novel we read is, in its fictional pose, purporting to be the memoir of Andy Collins (as we learn in the novel’s last sentence), writing about his cure from what was later called post-traumatic stress disorder.
I propose to look at Coleman’s novel—Andy Collins’s memoir—and the memoirs of Siegfried Sassoon (thinly disguised as novels) to see how this fictional character and this writer portrayed their cures. And I will contrast these two cases to the case of Robert Graves—who attempted to apply the same near-Freudian analysis as both an approach to his literary work and as a self-cure. Eventually, Graves chose to live with what he called his “neurasthenia” rather than have this approach to his writing made unavailable by a “cure.”
Robert Graves and Neurasthenia
Robert von Ranke Graves was born in Wimbledon on July 24, 1895. His father was Irish, an inspector of schools and a minor poet. His German mother pressed her religious idealism on Robert and his siblings. Graves’s days at Charterhouse, a public school, were mainly unhappy and stressful. His classmates resented him for his mother’s ideals and for Robert’s trying to live up to them. He found his juvenile poetry a useful way to deal with this emotional distress, and found an ambition: to be a serious poet and, eventually, a critic of poetry. Graves always maintained that his other prose—fiction, memoir, myth, gospel, all of it—was done in order to support his life as a poet.
Graves left Charterhouse in 1914, and he was suddenly caught up in the danger, deprivation, loneliness and horror of WWI, the “Great War.” He served with the Royal Welch Fusiliers on the Western Front, and was badly wounded at the Battle of the Somme in 1916. In 1929, Graves published Goodbye to All That, his memoir of service in the War. It is still regarded as one of the greatest war memoirs ever published, and it flourished in the rising flood of criticism over the way the war had been fought by the British government and military.
Graves’ biographies overflow with details of his war experiences, from his letters home and his letters to friends and literary correspondents. And of course the details from his memoir underlie these works, as well. Because his memoir shaped the memories and perceptions of WWI for so many, it is difficult to deal with Graves’s war experiences or his memoir itself without repeating what have now become clichés: Goodbye to All That was among the first war memoirs to provide the daily details of trench warfare to the British public and, probably unfortunately, its images of the violence and horror that mark any war—but WWI especially—may have become too familiar to all of us.
Having written to a friend that “France is the only place for a gentleman now,” Graves enlisted as a very young officer in 1914. The bare facts of his service seem to be these:
Having enlisted as a gentleman and officer in the Fusiliers, Graves spent several months in Britain, in charge of recruits and prisoners, until in May 1915 he was finally sent to France.
The first corpse he saw was that of a suicide.
After a leave back home to England, in September, he returned to the notoriously confused Battle of Loos, having entered what he described as “a black depression.”
He had by 1916 seen all the details—rats, mud, acres of unclaimed corpses between the lines, and the “dotty” behavior of wild-eyed officers and troops—that he wrote about in his memoir, and he himself had begun to feel suicidal, “empty and lost.”
By July 5, 1916, Graves had arrived at the trenches at Givenchy, when a raid was already being carried out as one of the first missions of the eventually futile Battle of the Somme.
And on July 20, as his platoon was moving through a French cemetery, an eight inch shell exploded just steps behind Graves. He was wounded in his hands and face (a splinter of marble from a shattered headstone lodged in his left eyebrow), with more serious wounds in his thigh and in his right lung, which was pierced completely through by a shell fragment.
Graves was given up for dead, left lying unconscious at a dressing station for over 24 hours. A burial detail noticed that he was still breathing, and he was quickly and roughly shipped to a hospital nearby, and then by train to the hospital in Rouen.
During the next few days, Graves’s mother received a telegram confirming his death, and his name appeared on the casualty list. By the time Graves had begun to recover and was in a hospital back in Highgate, he had read his own obituary in The Times. He pretended to enjoy the “joke” of his own death, but of course his escape from death he always regarded as a miracle; not only the shock but also his guilty sense of being miraculously spared, when so many others lost their lives, remained with him for the rest of his life (Seymour-Smith, 48). Graves thereafter referred to himself as one of the “double-fated,” indicating that he felt he had been spared for some future, important achievement. But also, after this trauma, he more damagingly, if correctly, referred to himself as a “neurasthenic”—sometimes ironically, sometimes very seriously and specifically.
His light and facetious tone in the poem “Escape,” his most direct literary treatment of the subject—the poem begins with the newspaper account of his death—disguises deep dread and anxieties as well as his fast-developing “neurasthenia,” one of the earliest terms for what has been called “shell-shock” then “battle-fatigue” and now, more aptly and more specifically, post traumatic stress disorder. In fact, the word “neurasthenia,” which pre-dated WWI, means only “nerve weakness.” It was a “patriot’s sophisticated coded term for ‘coward,’ ‘not quite one of us.’ It therefore meant ‘a sensitive man.’” For the remaining years of his life, Graves was a “neurasthenic” but with a difference: he pretended (after 1925) that he was not (Seymour-Smith, 49).
Neurasthenia was first described and offered as a diagnosis by George Miller Beard in 1869. Beard used this diagnosis to describe a number of symptoms: fatigue, anxiety, headache, neuralgia, and depression. The term is still in use as a diagnosis in the World Health Organization’s International Classification of Diseases but is not now a diagnosis in the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. This last seems ironic since neurasthenia was once thought overwhelmingly a disease of Americans—William James in fact called neurasthenia “Americanitis,” caused by the stresses of modern civilization on professionals. Freud used the term and included in its diagnosis a number of physical symptoms, such as fatigue, dyspepsia, intracranial pressure and spinal irritation, and he associated it with the sexual effects of low moral character, especially among males. (In fact, at one juncture Freud diagnosed his own depressions as neurasthenic, and “prescribed” for himself the use of cocaine, which he firmly believed had relieved his symptoms, and whose effects he delighted in relating in his letters to his fiancée Martha).
Neurasthenia became a rather common, even “popular” diagnosis for patients from the upper classes and those of artistic bent. The rest cure was the usual neurasthenia therapy, along with electrotherapy—later in 1895 repudiated by Freud for this purpose, and again after WWI. “Electrotherapy” had been used by all sides more or less as an adverse therapy to force malingerers back into combat. In Freud’s Memorandum on the Electrical Treatment of War Neurotics (in Eissler, 1986), he defended his colleague Julius von Wagner-Jauregg in a post-war inquiry, even though he did not see the value of the electrical treatment his friend had advocated and performed during the war. Freud summed up here what he thought about the treatment of war neuroses, even arguing for the superior efficacy of “what is known as the psycho-analytic school of psychiatry, which was brought into being by me…”
For those pre-war civilians whose symptoms included weakness, dizziness, and fainting, the diagnosis of neurasthenia became so widespread that the American drug company Rexall introduced their “Americanitis Elixir,” which was claimed to soothe the nervous symptoms of neurasthenia.
By 1930, in Britain and in the United States, the diagnosis of neurasthenia had all but disappeared among both military and civilian patients, to be replaced for military patients by the phrase “shell shock,” but in the early years of WWI the use of neurasthenia as a category of diagnosis was still very common.
After his near death, Graves’s nerves were weak; his range of activities was becoming greatly limited. He had difficulty talking to his parents. He wept constantly, easily. He could not bear to read newspaper accounts of the war; the “newspaper language” disgusted and repelled him (Seymour-Smith, 49). He spent some time with his friend Siegfried Sassoon, a fellow War Poet he had met in France. But Graves abruptly raced back to France, fleeing Sassoon’s home where his mother was holding séances attempting to contact her second son, who was killed in the Dardanelles. Graves heard noises at night, and he declared the house “haunted.” He described this experience in Goodbye to All That, and this episode’s appearance in the memoir is one of the many ways Graves offended and wore thin his friendship with Sassoon.
In France for the last time, back in the trenches on the Somme, the doctors found Graves ill with very serious bronchitis, and they sent him back to work in Britain. For the rest of the war, Graves served at minor posts in Britain, his physical health frail, and his emotional health in serious doubt. Ironically, given his own condition, Graves began a series of manipulative communications and requests for favors designed to arrange a medical board hearing that would save Sassoon from a court-martial for desertion after his public declaration against the war, and to have Sassoon instead sent to Craiglockhart, the “convalescent home for neurasthenics” in Edinburgh. This sequence of events, despite the fact that Sassoon’s symptoms were very successfully treated at Craiglockhart, was the beginning of mistrust and eventual hostility between Graves and Sassoon. One ironic outcome of the medical board Graves arranged for Sassoon was that Graves “got himself declared fit when he wasn’t.” Martin Seymour-Smith, Graves’s first biographer, says Graves “should have been in Craiglockhart himself; his nerves were in pieces, strange smells put him in trembling sweats, and any bang sent him flying for cover” (56). Graves broke down three times on the witness stand for Sassoon, weeping uncontrollably.
With an annual disability pension of £60, Graves was finally demobilized as “officially suffering from neurasthenia or shell-shock.” Seymour-Smith theorizes convincingly that the neurosis was caused when battle stripped men of “their necessary psychological defenses…to face aspects of themselves of which they were ignorant and therefore terrified them.” Some men were driven into fascism, he says, some into madness, some even into politics, but the experience drove “countless others into despair and failure” (76).
Graves would come to understand his condition somewhat differently, in the context of the new Freud-derived “talking cure” wielded at Craiglockhart by W.H.R. Rivers, but in the meantime, as he described it later in Goodbye to All That, he would awake to shells bursting on his bed at midnight. Strangers would suddenly seem to take on the faces of dead comrades. He could not use a telephone. Every landscape he saw evoked in his mind elaborate military plans for attacking or defending it. Meeting more than two new people in a single day would make it impossible to sleep. He stole everything “of uncertain ownership” (as one did in the trenches to survive). He was rough and uncouth in manner, and he lied his way out of every difficulty “in the time-honored army style.”
Craiglockhart and Shell-Shock
The response from the military and the civilian medical profession to the “shell-shock problem” was not standardized in its methods, its conception of the problem, or even in its aims (Webb, 346). As early as 1914, the doctors in British military hospitals were using the labels of “shell-shock” and “war hysteria” to cover a very long list of symptoms, including fatigue, irritability, dizziness, headaches and inability to concentrate (it is easy to see why the early term “neurasthenia” continued to be used). But shell-shock had more serious elements—suicides, the refusal to follow orders, complete mental breakdowns. The term shell-shock was named for one widely-believed theory of its cause, that the vacuum created by a bursting shell disturbed the cerebro-spinal fluid and upset the normal workings of the brain.
The most common cure for shell-shock was complete rest, far away from the fighting. Officers were generally sent home; this shifting from the trenches to home and back to the trenches was a very disorienting cycle, as Siegfried Sassoon notes, making both the trenches and home life seem illusory and unreal.
But for the regular soldier, almost always from the lower classes, a diagnosis of shell-shock led to much less civilized treatment: many military leaders took the view that in the cases of ordinary soldiers, who had fewer mental demands placed on them than were placed on officers, shell-shock was a sign of cowardly attempts to escape the front. By 1918, the British Army had identified two percent of their force who actually saw fighting, some 80,000 men, as suffering from shell-shock. But an even larger number of ordinary soldiers with the same symptoms had been labeled “malingerers,” and were sent back to the front lines. Other men committed suicide, deserted, or refused orders; many of these men who refused to follow orders were shot on the spot, and another 304 British soldiers were shot after court-martials. Still others received “Field Punishment Number One,” which entailed being strapped to a fixed object for two hours a day—sometimes for months at a time—and placed within range of enemy fire. One can only imagine the result of these punishments, just as one can only imagine the effects on loyalty to the cause or even to British civilization when, in such public view, in case after case, one class is so punished and another receives therapy—no matter the effectiveness of that therapy. Treatment in the German army for shell-shock was certainly harsh, as well, with perhaps more sufferers subjected to those very painful Wagner-Jauregg electrical shocks to convince them that combat was less threatening than was treatment.
The British military’s most well-known facility for treating shell-shock, Craiglockhart (or “Dottyville” as Siegfried Sassoon so memorably named it), was set up for dealing with increased numbers of psychological casualties after the Somme. Craiglockhart has an “important place in the development of British neuropsychiatry,” and an almost equal importance in British literary history since Sassoon and Wilfred Owen were treated there; the staff at Craiglockhart helped first apply Freud’s ideas about repression and the unconscious to the relatively new realization that a psychological stressor could result in physical symptoms. But in fact, despite his fame for being an early British Freudian, Dr. W.H.R. Rivers seemed open to a range of causes for the condition, since he mentioned one of the possible physical causes of shellshock to Graves, as related in Goodbye to All That:
Dr. W.H.R. Rivers told me later that the action of one of the ductless glands—I think the thyroid—caused this slow general decline in military usefulness, by failing at a certain point to pump its sedative chemical into the blood. Without its continued assistance a man went about his tasks in an apathetic and doped condition…It has taken some ten years for my blood to recover.
It is probably the case that the diagnosis of shell-shock covered such a huge range of symptoms and behaviors that any psychologist or psychiatrist attempting to treat shell-shock—even a reader of Freud’s works—had to stay open to, and receptive of, virtually any possible cause.
While Craiglockhart remains famous for its role in treating shell-shock, the hospital facility was only open, after all, for 28 months (Webb, 342). Its short term of service is directly due to the prevailing misinformed opinions of the military command regarding shell-shock and its treatment. The facility, housed in a run-down “hydropathic hotel” outside Edinburgh, was inspected by the War Office twice, and each time Craiglockhart’s commanding officer was removed—indicating the vast differences in opinion between the staff and the military. “There was considerable antagonism between the ‘chief medical mandarins’ from the War Office and the doctors in uniform who ran Craiglockhart” (Webb, 342). This antagonism was caused by the overtly stated skepticism of the War Office about both the diagnosis and the treatment offered. The military—and for the most part, the British public—believed in 1916 that shell-shock even among officers was a cover for malingerers who should be punished, certainly not sent out to the beautiful Scottish countryside.
And, probably as a result of this antagonism, there were a surprising number of changes in command at Craiglockhart. It was after the first such change, in October 1917, that all the original civilian staff resigned (Webb, 342-343), including Dr. W.H.R. Rivers, whose importance to British psychiatry and neurology can hardly be over-emphasized, but whose importance (and length of service) at Craiglockhart has apparently been very much over-emphasized—even though more generally his thinking is one foundation of modern treatments for post traumatic stress disorder. In fact, Rivers was the director of the two first psychological laboratories in Britain and a founding editor of the British Journal of Psychology; in recognition of his foundational work with shell-shock, his name was given to the Rivers Center, which treats patients with post traumatic stress disorder.
But in fact, the only patients treated at Craiglockhart were officers—and certainly none of these members of the officer class was ever tortured there, as has been alleged. But similarly, the popular image of life at the hospital, based on the reported treatment of Wilfred Owen and Siegfried Sassoon—“a subtle reprogramming taking the form of friendly chats with avuncular doctors over tea and scones”—only very rarely, if ever, was the case (Webb, 342). W.H.R. Rivers simply did not serve at Craiglockhart for very long at all. But it was during his service that Sassoon wrote in a letter to Robert Graves on October 11, 1917 that “My golf is improving steadily & I am now quite good at it. Have played 2 rounds every day lately.” He later notes however, that Rivers had been away from Craiglockhart during this period (letter in collections at Morris Library, Southern Illinois University).
But Rivers was “a pioneering therapist of war neuroses. While accepting Freud’s view that a patient’s dream life or traumatic hallucinations were key to his psychological condition, Rivers differed from Freud in rejecting the sex drive as the principal controlling factor in man’s makeup” (Hoffman, 154). This slight variance from the traditional Freudian view would have made it considerably easier for Rivers to counsel the homosexual Sassoon and Robert Graves, whose name is also frequently linked to Rivers, and who during the War was still attempting to shift away from his boyhood’s homoerotic leanings.
As a psychologist who had studied primitive cultures as well as the personality structure of modern man, who specialized in the diagnosis of war hysteria [yet another term current in WWI] and who was besides particularly interested in the problems of poetic communication, Rivers did far more than cure [Graves’s] neuroses. In Rivers’s scientific attempt to understand the self divided between the instinctual and the conscious life, Graves found a framework that he used for his own aesthetic for the next decade (Hoffman, 155).
Even if Graves so profited from Rivers’s ideas that he would use them in On English Poetry in 1921 and again in Poetic Unreason in 1925, it is still clear that he was not cured of his neurasthenia, nor was the situation immediately healing for many of the patients who were assigned to Craiglockhart.
Still, the therapies used at Craiglockhart are relevant to the history of shell-shock and neurasthenia, and particularly to the cases of Robert Graves and Siegfried Sassoon. But after Rivers left, the treatments at Craiglockhart became mundane and unconvincing. After Rivers’s Freud-based concepts, another technique was imported, that of treating neurosis with the neurosis-stimulant. Those patients afraid of noise were given noisy rooms near the road. Patients who had previously read for pleasure were forbidden to use the hospital library, and were forced to play sports, for example. During this regime only two percent of the patients improved (and it may have been this period during which the impressions and rumors of “torture” had their beginnings). These modes of therapy were in place from November 1917 until early 1918, when the decreased rates of success prompted another War Office inspection.
The later therapy then put into place by Arthur John Brock, after this 1918 inspection, was “ergotherapy,” or therapy by functioning. Through productively working on local farms or in local schools or on the hospital magazine The Hydra, the “shell-shocked” could “rediscover their links with an environment from which they had become detached” (Webb, 342-345). So it was prior to all this, during Rivers’s short tenure at Craiglockhart, that as Sassoon wrote in Sherston’s Progress,
In the daytime, sitting in a sunny room, a man could discuss his psychoneurotic symptoms with his doctor, who could diagnose phobias and conflicts and formulate them into scientific terminology. Significant dreams could be noted down, and Rivers could try to remove repressions.
But still there was the night:
But by night each man was back in his doomed section of horror-stricken Front Line, where the panic and struggle of some ghastly experience was reenacted among the livid faces of the dead. No doctor could save him, when he became the lonely victim of his dream disasters and delusions (Sassoon, 1936, 54).
Brock’s ergotherapy in fact was responsible for Wilfred Owen’s beginning to write his war poetry, after Brock suggested that he do so as a sort of return to work. Brock, like Rivers, was also an early practitioner who eventually came to understand the limitations of “a purely mechanistic scientific paradigm” to explain shell-shock.
Siegfried Sassoon, George Sherston, and Rivers’s
“Talking Cure”
An example of this broader approach, of discovering proximate psychological causes for shell-shock, is seen in the apparently successful treatment of Siegfried Sassoon. After his medical board hearing, Sassoon was immediately transferred to Craiglockhart for treatment. While this may have been absolutely justified on the basis of Sassoon’s state of mind—he saw corpses in Piccadilly and saw dead comrades appear at his bedside, even toward the end of his stay at Craiglockhart—Robert Graves hoped this diagnosis would prevent Sassoon’s being punished for A Soldier’s Declaration, Sassoon’s public statement that his opposition to the war made it impossible that he continue to serve. A court-martial on the charge of desertion, imprisonment, public disgrace—a public debate on his “cowardice”—all were very real possibilities for Sassoon.
In his barely-fictionalized novels, Sassoon tells a version of these events more sympathetic to himself. In Memoirs of an Infantry Officer Sassoon explains the origins of his new feelings of pacifism: his realization that Britain had no War Aims other than possible access to new oil fields; the refusal of the British government to negotiate an end to the war, even after months of stalemate on the battlefields; and his growing conviction that the war was being prolonged by the stupidity of an inept military command and by the greed of the war industries. That he felt this was a war with no real explanation—a war that pitted class against class, a war in which the home front had access only to purposefully misguided conceptions of the war—caused enormous psychological conflict with Sassoon’s and Graves’s idea that “France is the only place for a gentleman now.” Both men continued to believe that it was a gentleman’s duty to serve his men and to try to protect them (Sassoon eventually voluntarily returned to the front, as did Graves)—even while loyalty to Britain meant that officers and men should follow their orders and pursue the aims of the military, however ill-conceived these aims might be.
Indeed, the Battle of the Somme illustrates the similar national conflict that was beginning to dominate thinking about the aims and logic of WWI. The losses of men were so appalling, the gains and losses of territory so meaningless, that intellectuals in Britain like those who Graves believed had “duped” Sassoon into his denunciation of the War, were beginning to be heard. During only one day of the Battle of the Somme, more than 50,000 British soldiers died walking into direct German fire, and this enormous sacrifice did not advance the front by a single foot. For that matter, the entire front moved less than five miles in three years, but a total of 3,000,000 lives were lost in attempting to change the positions of the trenches and the deployed armies. But Sassoon’s conflict between these facts and the ideas of the anti-war pacifists may be seen in his caricature of the fumbling “Doctor Macamble,” the entirely ineffective civilian Ph.D. pacifist who visits “Slateford Hospital” and asks Sherston to turn on Rivers.
Intellectuals back in Britain may have been demanding a negotiated settlement, but for the troops in the trenches, it was still war, and they were still loyal. And Graves and Sassoon both felt a strong loyalty to the troops they had led, however misplaced the loyalty of the troops to the war effort might have been. This magnified the conflict in mind and behavior for both men, and if not a cause of their shell-shock, certainly was an important contributing factor.
The first few sentences of Sherston’s Progress make this dilemma clear:
To be arriving at a shell-shock hospital in a state of unmilitant defiance of military authority was an experience peculiar enough to stimulate my speculations about the immediate future… The self-dramatizing element in my mind anticipated something sensational. After all, a mad-house would be only a few degrees less grim than a prison, and I was still inclined to regard myself in the role of a “ripe man of martyrdom”…
But the unhistrionic part of my mind remembered that the neurologist member of my medical board had mentioned someone called Rivers…a stroke of luck for me. Rivers was obviously some sort of great man (8-9).
The “stroke of luck” that Sherston was assigned to the correct doctor and the correct treatment for his shell shock caused, at least in part, by his internalized conflict of ideas is important indeed (just as the actual assignment was for Sassoon as well). Sassoon devotes the entire first chapter of Sherston’s Progress to a fictional version of his treatment by Rivers, upon whom Sherston lavishes praise and whom he calls his “father-confessor.” In fact this first chapter is titled “Rivers.” This use of the great man’s name in the chapter title and in the memoir is a sort of tribute, and indeed, Sassoon’s gratitude for Rivers’s treatment of his moral conflict is reflected in the novel almost every time Rivers is mentioned.
The conflict underlying the symptoms of Graves and Sassoon is almost precisely the same as that conflict felt by Andy Collins in Charles Coleman’s 1980 novel Sergeant Back Again. Andy Collins, an ex-medical student, is a front-line medic in Vietnam who over-identifies himself and his beliefs, psychologically and even externally, with the men whose injuries he treats. At the same time, he is working with an anti-war group, leaking true battlefield casualty numbers to American media, which the military—who want to control news going back to the “home front”—view as treason. Thus, like Sassoon/Sherston, Andy Collins is facing the dual danger of psychological trauma that must be treated and overcome, alongside the real threat of military imprisonment or a life-long commitment to a Veterans Administration Hospital psychiatric ward.
Sassoon writes in Sherston’s Progress what seems a very emotionally underplayed narrative of his time at Craiglockhart (a display of the famous British reserve and the reserve of a Jewish country gentleman, in all likelihood, but also a device that makes Sherston an unreliable and occasionally unbelievable narrator). Sassoon makes it very clear that Sherston’s “shell-shock,” while it may involve minor hallucinations, is the result of his moral conflict regarding the aims of the war and the waste of men’s lives:
One evening I asked whether he [Rivers] thought I was suffering from shell-shock.
“Certainly not,” he replied.
“What have I got, then?”
“Well, you appear to be suffering from an anti-war complex.” We both of us laughed at that (10).
A seemingly minor moment; but Rivers’s opinion of the cause of Sherston’s case does not appear to change during the course of the novel. The two men have more very genteel conversations, all of them relaxed and natural-seeming and none of them combative or stressful, and none of them more revelatory than this. Their talks revolve around this “complex,” and Sherston’s thoughts are almost always centered on what the troops will think of him should he return to the front or should he make a public statement of his pacifism.
Sassoon wanted out of Craiglockhart so he could return to the trenches. In a letter to Graves dated October 11, 1917, Sassoon wrote “Rivers is back. He says they can only pass me for G.S. [general service] if I have a Board, which is satisfactory.” On October 21st Sassoon complained that “I had a Board last Wednesday and they gave me sick leave till November 20th!!” That general service status back with the troops was Sassoon’s goal is best understood when he complains to Graves on November 18, 1917 that “My Board has been re-postponed to Nov. 27 (pending an assurance from the W.O. [War Office] that they will put no obstacles in the way of my returning to the Fatherland—it will be G.S. or nothing.” Even more specifically, Sassoon wrote on November 21, 1917 “…but I can’t see beyond the war & I don’t care if I’m dead or alive…” (letters in Southern Illinois University Collections).
The Craiglockhart section of Sherston’s Progress ends when a medical board, again very underplayed and very minimal—and very similar to the later board scene in Sergeant Back Again—finds Sherston fit for service. And, it is regaining his prior status that is apparently of most interest to Sherston: “Without knowing it, two-thirds of the medical board had restored me to my former status. I was now ‘an officer and a gentleman,’ again” (50).
In fact, Sherston seems always to be less concerned with himself than with the suffering of other men at Craiglockhart who exhibit more profound effects of shell-shock:
…in the sweating suffocation of nightmare, in paralysis of limbs, in the stammering of dislocated speech. Worst of all, in the disintegration of those qualities through which they had been so gallant and selfless and uncomplaining—this, in the finer types of men, was the unspeakable tragedy of shell-shock; it was in this that their humanity had been outraged by those explosives which were sanctioned and glorified by the Churches; it was thus that their self-sacrifice was mocked and maltreated—they who in the name of righteousness had been sent out to maim and slaughter their fellow-men. In the name of civilization these soldiers had been martyred, and it remained for civilization to prove that their martyrdom wasn’t a dirty swindle (54).
That Sherston has these thoughts after his last session with Rivers indicates the degree to which Rivers’s therapy had been directed at Sherston’s understanding of his conflicted ideas, leaving Sherston to make adjustments in behavior. And, not only is this passage a beautiful summing up of Sherston’s attitude toward the war and the swindle that had been forced onto all the troops, but we should note the degree to which this language and attitude presages the later language and the ultimate understandings of his conflicts that Andy Collins realizes after his therapy at Chambers Pavilion. In WWI, the divide between the soldiers fighting the war and those who opposed or questioned the war was not so public as was the American divide over the Vietnam War; mass media may have made the later divide both a more explicit and more constant national discussion. But apparently at least some victims of shell-shock in WWI were suffering from the same internalized realization of their nation’s lack of commitment to a vague war purpose, just as did soldiers in later generations, in later wars.
Thus was Sassoon—or Sherston (we must always remember that this is reported in a novelized memoir)—apparently successfully treated for his shell-shock, or his anti-war complex. And of course, Sassoon went on to write this version of his memoirs as did Graves (and as did our later fictional memoirist, Andy Collins). But Sassoon’s poetry, thought once to be among the very best of the War Poetry, did not continue to develop or to be well-received by the public or by critics. And even though his novels of WWI and later were quite successful, even winning national literary prizes, Sassoon ended as a poet whose name is mentioned only in the context of the War and of the War Poets, and his tempestuous private life sometimes seemed to overwhelm his career as a writer, at least in the public mind.
Andy Collins, Sergeant Back Again, and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
It is in the later context of the Vietnam War that Charles Coleman’s Sergeant Back Again, a much more detailed and dramatic example of a Rivers-like approach to shell-shock—by then beginning to be called Post Traumatic Stress Disorder—is set. The novel’s focus is the finally successful treatment of Andy Collins, whom the reader first sees as a front-line medic in Vietnam who is having a complete psychological breakdown. After he is withdrawn from the battlefield—not quickly enough—we see Collins nearly catatonic in his psychiatrist’s office at Chambers Pavilion, Brooke Army Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, Texas (the long address is important in the novel). After Dr. Nieland’s black and white name plaque, the first objects mentioned are Collins’s diaries and notebooks stacked on Nieland’s desk. Collins had been writing letters to himself in the field, in the names and even in the assumed identities of the wounded soldiers he treated at a Field Surgical Hospital. This is Collins’s first attempt to rid himself of his conflicts—essentially writing fiction about (and “by”) the wounded in the attempt to understand, and reconcile his mind to, the sacrifices of these men. And, as he attempted this self-cure, he began to disappear, to become a void, with only an “untouchable part” at the heart of himself that he could not understand.
Nieland’s first piece of advice to Collins is that
…in your world, right now, perhaps there is such a thing as the untouchable part of you. But, Collins, it’s not really a living thing. Except for the fantasy life which you lend to it. But it’s not really alive.
Nieland realizes that Collins’s act of fictionalizing his patients, of pouring his now-flawed personality into them, had made Collins believe he was empty. Nieland points at the stacks of notebooks and warns, “The whole picture is here in your own language written in your own hand.”
Collins’s first attempt, on the battlefield, to cure himself by writing about the trauma has failed him, and failed him spectacularly. Because they were his patients, Collins has over- identified with his “characters,” and he cannot re-discover his own identity.
Even with the device of the letters, Collins had not been able to create a distance between himself and the patients he treated, who continue to live in his mind. After four months with his field unit “he was uttering disjointed words and phrases, until little remained of his coherency.” Finally, his commanding officer and others realize that “Specialist Collins was talking as though he were the very patient being rejoined.” As he had become more completely identified with his patients, sometimes clutching at his body as though the maimed limbs being treated were his own, he is powerless to save these men—a complete lack of real or psychological agency finally proven to him when a sergeant whom Collins had treated earlier is brought back to the Field Hospital, this time dead.
“There it was, undone, Collins’s best resolutions, the stamp of his skill and the only reason he had for going on had finally and completely turned against him.” Collins goes outside and uses his scalpel to mutilate his face and to cut one of his wrists. Though he is stopped before he can kill himself, he arrives back in the U.S. at Chambers Pavilion catatonic and empty.
Ironically, it is another patient who first gives voice to the displacement in Collins’s mind, mirroring that of America in the Vietnam years (just as Sassoon’s and Graves’s displacement mirrored that in Britain in WWI).
And we were supposed to be the living embodiment…of a concept, an idea, an ideal…something so absurdly American…and only this war, in that country, under these exact circumstances and this precise moment in the evolution of this country, could have produced a displacement of this magnitude.
The patient with this insight is a former Professor of Asian Studies whose own experience with the reality of war took place in a country he had studied and whose culture he had revered. This patient, Pollard, had been driven mad by what he calls the “crimson parallax,” his idealism destroyed by battle in a society that had by now adapted itself to more than one invading, colonializing army. Collins, too, begins to use the description “crimson parallax” to describe what he sees around himself at Chambers Pavilion. “He felt ashamed of himself, his home, and his homeland.”
Nieland’s supervisor, Penderspot, advances “psychological theories of behavior that had been popular in the early post-WWII years.” The social and medical ambivalence about shell-shock that is illustrated by the history of Craiglockhart and by Sassoon’s thinly veiled memoir had continued well into the 1930s, especially in Britain where on the one hand shell-shock victims were eligible for pensions and on the other hand, as at least one British writer claimed, “…these patients succumb to ‘shock’ because they get something out of it,” going on to describe shell-shock as “unconscious cowardice.”
But in the United States, by 1939 every division had a psychiatrist in its organizational chart, and the military was using the term “exhaustion” as a first diagnosis, to be followed if needed by a diagnosis of “combat stress reaction,” both labels involving a similar but much more highly developed list of symptoms, including autonomic nerve arousal, suicidal thoughts, hypervigilance, mistrust of others, and extreme fears of losing control. Even during the early Vietnam War era, doctors’ opinions were divided about sending CSR patients back to their units. But later in the war, if observed symptoms lasted more than 30 days, the diagnosis of the longer-lasting disability “Post Traumatic Stress Disorder” began to be used.
Nieland, poring over “a cluster of rare and often contradictory syndromes,” is led “into an intense search for a common denominator, some subtle precipitating strain.” Nieland considers Collins symbolic…of every patient in here” since “they’re all compensating for losses.”
Nieland sounds much like W.H.R. Rivers when he presses his ideas on Penderspot:
What we’re dealing… with is a crisis of personal morality. Of right and wrong in the most intimate private sense. Of clashing values, of contradictory roles, of conflicting beliefs and responsibilities, which we see reflected daily in the tumultuous confrontations right here in our own country…. a national neurosis…a disorder of conscience.
Now, as the reader comes to understand Nieland’s relating the psychological casualties to the conflict of war and idealism (much as does Pollard) the reader must keep in mind that the fiction of Coleman’s novel is that the book in the reader’s hands is a memoir written by Andy Collins—as we learn in the novel’s last sentence. This very ironic and effective literary device, also used for example by Anthony Burgess, demands that the reader reconsider or even reread the novel in an entirely new light, forcing a quite different, even sometimes opposite, second understanding of the work, and making the first reading entirely ironic. After his cure, Collins reconstructs his problems and his release from them, so Nieland’s words are in fact an explanation written later, mediated if you will, by Andy Collins. Can there be a narrator any more “unreliable” than a narrator who blurs fiction by claiming to have written the actual book in the reader’s hands, and to have written the book as part of the act of curing himself of a psychological disordering?
As we watch some patients fail and others succeed, as the casualties continue to arrive at Chambers Pavilion, as we learn about the unique dimensions of Black veterans’ reactions, for example, we see Collins coming closer and closer to erasing his sense of loss (by means of literature) and resolving the crimson parallax (by writing about it and defining it). The compelling scenes of bad group therapy, of mutiny in a church service, of a surprisingly un-awkward “mixer” all allow our fictional author of the memoir, Collins, to show us instances of Nieland’s penetrating analysis. After tossing off a list of symptoms that is almost identical to Robert Graves’s fears of another breakdown, aphasia, nightmares, and guilt, Nieland explains to another patient, Eddie, the roots of Eddie’s most obvious symptom:
You stutter because some protective device wants you to stutter…excuse you from the responsibilities and pressures of being normal in the cold, cruel world…the stuttering permits you to bridge back and forth between the regressive, infantile retreat and the more dominant part of you, which is normal, mature, healthy.
Remember, again, that these words, these descriptions, are the work of med-school dropout Andy Collins. He is continuing, in his memoir, to understand returning Vietnam psychological casualties better and better, with each chapter, perhaps with each draft. He is no longer writing letters in the voices of his patients, but is writing about the casualties at Chambers Pavilion, and writing in his own voice. With Collins, we see the cure of literature literally working before our eyes, as we read the novel.
The 90-day threat of the end of therapy and the probability of a life sentence to a VA hospital, the threat of the treason charges, the threat of electro-convulsive therapy (having been declared a sometimes useful final resort—though of course at a lower voltage than the Germans used in WWI) and its results all are looming closer as the novel continues. As the novel/memoir accelerates, Collins is calmer, more rational, and more intellectually interested in his surroundings: he describes Nieland’s reaction while listening to his previously dictated summary of Collins’ case, “the emerging pattern of syndromes derives from a cultural neurosis.” And with this simple device, Collins’s grasp of the issue is made perfectly clear (very didactically, admittedly, since Nieland may be dictating a professional speech or article). We read Collins’s remembered or constructed version of Nieland’s observations on the case of Collins himself:
… acute depersonalization…psychosis…massive deterioration of the persona occurring concomitantly with his bizarre propensity to attempt a psychic reanimation of separated pieces of human flesh and even corpses…even a surreptitious assumption of certain alien personalities: i.e., soldiers whom he was engaged in treating in a medical capacity.
If Andy Collins, after his treatment ends, can describe his own diagnosis so cogently as he writes his memoir, then his personality is certainly re-integrating, as the time and skill spent in writing the memoir would in fact demand.
Treatment for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, at least in part because of now measurable changes in neuroendocrinology and neuroanatomy in PTSD patients, has been marked by the use of cognitive therapy and, now more frequently, medication. In Sergeant Back Again the medication most often mentioned is Thorazine, the drug which has such anesthetic effects on the Chambers Pavilion patients. (In later years, more specifically-targeted, more recently discovered medications are used, such as the anticonvulsant and mood stabilizer Lamictal, or lamotrigine).
Harold Kudler’s essay, “Psychiatric Insights,” is an astute explanation of the successful and unsuccessful cases in Coleman’s Chambers Pavilion. Kudler supplies the context of professional psychological standards and approaches, changing from Rivers-like psychoanalytic theory to biological (now pharmaceutical) psychiatry. This context of the relatively sudden change in the psychological professions brings a revelatory clarity to Sergeant Back Again. The spectrum of psychological methods used in Chambers Pavilion mirrors the conflict in the profession, from the prescription of thorazine and whatever else is on the medicine cart to the methods of Nieland, who works to see past surface observations and to find causes. Nieland diagnoses Andy Collins to be suffering from a dissociation of identity, theoretically caused by a repression of memories which Collins must eventually understand and put into proper perspective with Nieland’s help. This would be a rare approach these days, after the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual III solidified the rise to power of what Kudler calls the “calculatedly atheoretical” wing of the American Psychiatric Association. W.H.R. Rivers and his Freud-derived approach to shell-shock would still be in the minority, even today.
The novel/memoir goes on in the dictation scene to delineate the course of treatment Nieland prescribes for Collins: rational therapy “to use this patient’s perceptual working and his own distortions of language against him,” and what earlier might even have been called ergotherapy, “to force him into as many and varied social situations as possible…not blatantly clinical…social realities in a non-hospital setting.”
But Collins’s final reintegration climactically begins when in a daze he suddenly feels compelled to assemble an effigy of mud, a “man of many parts” figuratively including all the lost and severed limbs of his patients. Collins makes the effigy from San Antonio River mud, “so we may know ourselves by you,” he says. He covers the “clay corpse” with his fatigue shirt “and walked out of the woods.”
Interestingly, Collins is violating Pavilion policy that evening by missing a check-in phone call and the evening bed-check as he wanders the San Antonio River, placing his medical board hearing in jeopardy; so too Sherston places his board hearing in jeopardy by wandering away to have tea with an astronomer and have a look through his telescope which, perhaps symbolically, is out of adjustment and refuses to work. The fictional Rivers understands Sherston’s violating the schedule just as Nieland understands Collins’s violation, and each make sure that the board hearings will nonetheless be positive. And even the real W.H.R. Rivers, in an extraordinary parallel action, apparently “put the fix in” for Sassoon. On December 7, 1917, Sassoon wrote Graves:
Was passed G.S. at Craiglockhart on Nov. 26. The Board asked if I had changed my views on the war, I said I hadn’t, which seemed to cause surprise. However, Rivers obtained, previously, an assurance from a high quarter that no obstacles would be put in the way of my going back to the sausage machine (Southern Illinois University Collections).
Sherston refers to “the agitation created by board-cutting” having caused an “ableptical effect on my introspectiveness.” After using that very rare technical term for blindness that the real Rivers might have used in his ground-breaking studies of human vision, Sherston says “the episode provided a sort of bridge between psychological disquietude and a calm acceptance of ‘the inevitable’” (50). In Sherston’s underplayed diction, this means he was resigned to returning to the front as he longed to do, even as he knew he was placing himself in danger again. This is the mark of the practical result of his cure: “In other words, I ceased to worry.”
In Collins’s case, when Nieland sees his patient the next day, the psychiatrist knows immediately, simply by observing his manner, that Collins’s treatment has worked. “You returned [yourself] to a civilian by stripping your military identity,” says Nieland. And, Collins of course depersonalized all those unresolved identifications with his patients as he covered the effigy with that military identity—his fatigue shirt. And from this point forward, with a few minor setbacks—“You can’t expect it to go away in one night,” Nieland says, realistically—Collins is social, focused, intelligent and understanding. And, no longer one of the wasted, he begins to write his memoir, and judged by the quality of that memoir, the cure of literature works for Andy Collins.
Robert Graves and the Cure of Literature
The example of Robert Graves and his attempts to cure his shell-shock, expressing and mediating his symptoms and conflicts in literature and in what may be the most elaborated version of the cure of literature, is a very different instance from the fictional Andy Collins, and a very different instance from Sassoon and his fictional George Sherston. Graves rather held himself apart from other psychological casualties, insisting on using the word “neurasthenia” rather than “shell-shock,” and seeking psychological help while denying doing so. He used the psychological knowledge he gained to form an aesthetic and a critical approach to poetry. But he created an aesthetic that led him to fear that a cure of his shell-shock would destroy his ability to write his poetry, and he eventually stopped his efforts to escape his neurasthenia, instead saying good-bye to all that by means of his memoir.
But was Graves successful? Or did his neurasthenia continue, affecting his habits of work, his habits of mind, his relationships with women and eventually the critical reception and reputation of his work? In Graves’s case, did the cure of literature work?
Apparently, Graves himself was never assigned to Craiglockhart, as has sometimes been thought. In a letter to the Modern Language Quarterly in 1966, hoping to set the record straight once and for all, Graves wrote:
I was never a patient of Dr. W.H.R. Rivers, as were Siegfried Sassoon and Wilfred Owen. But he and his colleague Henry Head (Robert Nichols’ psychiatrist) were my friends and for a while I accepted their general theory of a “subconscious self”. . . but not Freud’s deformation of it. No Freudian I nor were they (quoted in Seymour-Smith, 27).
Graves visited these two doctors on a regular basis during his post-war years at Oxford, but he steadfastly maintained that the three were only friends and that he was simply interested in their theories. But he used, rather desperately, these theories for self-treatment. In 1929 he wrote in Goodbye to All That, “I had decided to see as few people as possible, to stop all work, and cure myself. I had already learned the rudiments of morbid psychology from talks with Rivers, and from his colleague, Dr. Henry Head, the neurologist.” In 1957, this passage was among the many that Graves deleted from the revised edition of his memoir. “With great disdain he would ever after explain that he had learned all there was to know from the man who had ‘invented’ it” (Seymour-Smith, 84).
As further proof of Graves’s own knowledge of psychoanalysis and of at least Rivers’s slightly modified Freudianism, note that in 1924 Graves published the now very rare The Meaning of Dreams, with its chapters on “Past Theories as Far as Freud” and “Theory of Double Self.” Perhaps most relevant are the chapters on “Survival of the Past and Other Problems” and “Practical Benefits of Interpretation”—and of course “Dreams and Poetry.”
Miranda Seymour, in Robert Graves: Life on the Edge, the most recent of the Graves biographies, argues that while Graves may never have been one of Rivers’s patients, and later pretended to despise “all forms of psychoanalysis,” he was actually a very frequent visitor to Rivers’s rooms in Cambridge by summer of 1921. Graves wrote to Edmund Blunden that Rivers was “the greatest living psychologist” and to Sassoon, Graves wrote that Rivers “is all that really matters.” It was Rivers, Seymour writes, “who encouraged Graves to lay [aside] his ghostly tormentor by raising him again in his poetry” (105-106).
Compare Rivers’s advice to Graves to the sequence of resolution in Sergeant Back Again when Andy Collins must “lay aside his ghostly tormentor” by creating the mud effigy of all his patients. The psychological distance thus created leaves Collins no longer dissociated from his own identity and then allows him to further recover by writing the memoir that is the novel. But Graves would raise his “ghostly tormentor” again and again in his post-war poetry.
Graves’s poetry first came to the attention of British readers during the war when he was first identified as one of the Rhyming Musketeers then, more seriously, as a very fine War Poet (as he has continued to be seen in British popular culture). War poets and war poems were popular on the home front, as shown in the strong sales of collections like A Treasury of War Poems (1917) and Poems of the Great War (1916); Graves’s father, A.P. Graves, saw his “Brothers in Arms,” a cheerily patriotic promise of victory, published in the latter.
Though he was considered by some to be the very best of the War Poets, even early on Graves seemed overwhelmed by the emotional effects of war, no matter the public reception of his work. In what I consider one of his best war poems, “A Dead Boche,” Graves cannot move past description and disgust to a larger, more emotionally-based theme, even if the poem is “an undeniably forceful protest against the horrors of violent death.”
…Today I found in Mametz Wood
A certain cure for lust of blood
Where, propped against a shattered trunk,
In a great mess of things unclean,
Sat a dead Boche; he scowled and stunk
With clothes and face a sodden green
Big-bellied, spectacled, crop-haired,
Dribbling black blood from nose and beard.
Shocking, but in a strange way almost emotion-less, focusing on “the filthiness of war’s leavings,” the poem does not go on to “some sort of sympathetic understanding.” For the increasingly “sealed-off” Graves, the dead Boche is not, nor ever was, a person. Douglas Day, who began to write of Graves in the 1960s, goes on to note “we can recognize here the same fastidious revulsion from things grossly physical that marks so much of Graves’s poetry through his career” (12-13). Graves was a very Georgian war poet, Day maintains: Graves’s work from 1915-1918 that deals with the war in France “is strongly governed by the impulses toward the fanciful and quaint with which his background and early reading had equipped him” (Day, 13). But this approach quickly became an emotional armor against the psychological effects of the trenches. And, just as Andy Collins in Sergeant Back Again tries to armor himself against the trauma of battle by over-identifying with his patients and thus loses his own identity, the opposite technique of Graves’s “revulsion from the physical” has its own dangers as well.
By the time of Country Sentiment (1929), there were few direct references to World War I in Graves’s work. The war had become a sense of foreboding, a danger under the surface of the everyday world. The war horrors in the poems have become indirect and on the surface minimized: a mother’s warning to a daughter, for example, that she will suffer for her simple kindness to passing soldiers is one of very few references to the military. But “the elves and fauns of the Georgian phase were now metamorphosing, perhaps through the warping alchemy of the war, into the more grotesque shapes of trolls and ogres; and the playful goblins who romped through Over the Brazier [one of Graves’s collections of war poems] were now becoming, by the same distorting process either brooding ghosts or the old gods of long-forgotten religions” (Day, 25).
Consider the subject of just one of these poems: “Rocky Acres,” for example, long considered one of the best of Graves’s poems, is about old pagan gods waiting to ambush wandering humans, or on another level, “psychological menaces” lurking to “ensnare the mind” of those wandering types who have not been equipped by modern civilization or religion to cope with these “dark places” (Day, 26).
Graves’s war neurosis continued to affect him through his postwar years at Oxford, while he studied for his degree. Because of his condition, he was granted permission to live outside the city, on Boar’s Hill. By that time, Boar’s Hill had become a small colony for poets, including two other war poets, Robert Nichols and Edmund Blunden, who was “at this time as nervous as Graves himself” (Day, 27).
In January 1918 Graves married Nancy Nicholson. Though he was of course then devoted to her, she could not “have been much of a balm for his jangled nerves.” She was an ardent early feminist; she wore trousers, insisted on using her own name, distributed literature about birth control. Graves seemed to believe her theories about the “inherent superiority of the female, since from 1918 on, Graves wrote many poems praising this female superiority. And consider of course, his The White Goddess, a book revered by feminists of a later generation” (Day, 22).
Peter Quenell met Graves in 1920 and wrote:
…At Islip the Quixotic man of learning had not yet definitely taken control. He was as vulnerable as he was easily impressionable, and still exhibited the wounded features of a shell-shocked public schoolboy, who had gone straight from Charterhouse to a line regiment, had been shot through the body on some Flemish battlefield and temporarily left for dead. In common with many survivors of the battle, he wore the strained and troubled expression of a young man who had lately escaped from a volcano (Quennell, 36).
Graves called his work in The Pier-Glass (1921) “more aggressive and disciplinary.” Critics have called these poems “sardonic and “scornful.” Here, they believe, Graves is looking for a cure for his sickness: the poems “depict the struggles of men and women who are seeking to relieve their minds of painful memories” (Day, 30). In the title poem, the living ghost of a woman haunts a room where she had been a party to a violent crime. In another, “Down,” an ill man in nightmarish agony tries to avoid the abyss of madness by focusing on his childhood. In “Reproach” and “Raising the Storm” an angry and unjust God either punishes mankind for imagined sins or ignores man altogether. Others, like “Morning Phoenix,” deal with the very real fear of all-consuming love.
While living on Boar’s Hill and pursuing his degree, Graves realized that “the touch of shell-shock” was still more serious than he’d thought, and “war horror overcame me again” (Graves, 1929, 383). He once again changed his mind about seeking help, and began his visits to consult Rivers in Cambridge, who referred him to a nerve specialist in London. His nephew, R.P. Graves, writes in his three-volume biography of Graves hurrying away to consult Rivers after a village game of football (R.P. Graves, 1987, 243-266). Even after two more years of these attempts at self-cure (and even if informed by Rivers and Head’s work), Graves’s father wrote
Robby…hesitates greatly in speech and sometimes has to struggle hard to regain a dropped strand of thought. He protests too that railway travelling is a great trouble to him. I only trust he may grow out of these nervous conditions: I am not at all sure that his psychoanalysis is the best preparation for complete recovery from them (diary entry, 16 April 1923, quoted in R.P. Graves, 1987, 285).
It is abundantly clear that after the war, Graves began to see the act of writing poetry as another mode of self-cure. He “now saw his writing as at least in part a curative technique with which to master and clear up his war neurosis. He was under the necessity of laying the ghosts not only of his comrades who had died in the war but of his own self-reproach for having survived” (Cohen, 25). In fact, Graves was very open about the issue in the literary criticism he wrote during the 1920s. In On English Poetry he used Freudian theories to explain the very act of composing poetry and in Poetic Unreason Graves claims that
For the poet, the writing of poetry accomplishes a certain end, irrespective of whether the poem ever finds another reader but himself; it enables him to be rid of the conflicts between his sub-personalities. And for the reader, without necessarily any direct detailed regard to the history of the poet, the reading of poetry performs a similar service; it acts for him as a physician of his mental disorders (2).
Good poetry resolves mental or emotional conflicts. Bad poetry is that which does not do so (this may explain a great deal about Graves’s idiosyncratic, even hostile, reading of other poets like Yeats and Thomas). Graves was very specific, for decades, about his aims in writing poetry during this early period: in The Common Asphodel (1949) Graves writes
As a neurasthenic, I was interested in the newly- expounded Freudian theory: when presented with English reserve and common sense by W.H.R. Rivers, who did not regard sex as the sole impulse in dream making or assume that dream-symbols are constant, it appealed to me as reasonable (vii).
In Goodbye to All That, Graves said that Country Sentiment was “a book of romantic poems and ballads” written “to forget about the war” (342). And by the time of Whipperginny in 1932, Graves was still saying the poems in the earlier book were “products of the desire to escape from a painful war neurosis into an Arcadia of amatory fantasy.”
For example, consider one of the poems from Whipperginny, “The Bedpost.” Graves himself uses this poem to illustrate how “bankrupt” [Graves’s word] the original version was. It was in early drafts simply a sentimental story of a little girl amusing herself with the notion that her bedpost was telling her bloodthirsty old legends and ghost stories. When Graves rewrote the poem he strengthened the sexual imagery and emphasized the phallic properties of the bedpost. Only then did the poem become a “proper therapeutic device” (Day, 74-75).
Now this grave young warrior standing
With uncovered head
Tells her stories of old battles
As she lies in bed:
The phallic references are actually slight, but the poem ends with the young girl falling rather in love with her imagined story-teller:
As a post he shall stay rooted
For yet many years,
Until a maiden shall release him
With pitying tears.
But Betsy likes the bloodier stories,
Clang and clash of fight,
And Abel wanes with the spent candle—
‘Sweetheart, good-night!’
This single poem shows Graves’s early aesthetics at work. He is writing a children’s story, nearly a ballad, and yes, he revised to add details that would illustrate a psychological conflict: innocence and sexuality. But even the first version is not exactly a sentimental ballad or poem for children: the battles described are very gory, with kings stabbing guests in their bed, the Emperor’s daughters killing their father’s murderers, the farmer’s sons fighting the Giant Gog. This is Graves’s violence from the underworld—his war memories—welling up into the nursery. And the young girl who refuses to release the spell on Abel because she “likes the bloodier stories” is not exactly a paragon of child-like compassion or virtue.
If these ideas sound at all contradictory, they were developed over a period of psychological stress, and during this period Graves himself was quite conflicted about whether he really wanted a cure for his neurasthenia. In Goodbye to All That Graves says
Somehow I thought that the power of writing poetry, which was more important to me than anything else I did, would disappear if I allowed myself to get cured; my Pier-Glass haunting would end and I would become merely a dull easy writer.
It seemed less important to me to be well than to be a good poet (381).
This dichotomy of desire, says Day, this irreconcilable conflict, eventually made Graves decide to minimize emotional intensity in his poems, to create a poetry of detachment. He rejected subjectivity, and the decision to do so damaged his poetry. Graves became “essentially a romantic poet whose themes are entirely personal, stemming as they do from his own complex maladjustment between the mind and the body, between the intellect and the emotions…between the need for tension and fear and the longing for peace and stability” (Day, 36). Day further argues that even by the time of Mockbeggar Hall in 1923, Graves already was “attempting to avoid his real self…to make himself over into a different sort of person,” trying to “divorce his poetry from his own emotions and to develop a style and an attitude that would provide him with a sort of shield against his own conflicts” (69). Graves’s poetry became satiric and cynically objective, say some critics. (For a thorough and sympathetic reading of Graves’s early poetry and its relation to his theories and to his shell-shock, see Frank Kersnowski’s The Early Poetry of Robert Graves: The Goddess Beckons. 2002. Austin: University of Texas Press).
It was Graves’s war memoir that most decisively put the war behind him—if indeed any of his work completely did so. It is a memoir of what he called his neurasthenia and of the shell-shock of others as much as a memoir of war. In Goodbye to All That Graves admits that he felt, before the Somme offensive, that the food and the outdoor work made France, except for “wounds, gas, and the accidents of war,” not at all an unhealthy place. But he and his fellow officers—usually between 23 and 33 years old—knew what faced them. An officer’s first three weeks were to “find his way about,” and for the next four months he was at his peak, unless severe shock set in early due to some trauma. After those four peak months, neurasthenia began to eat away at the officer’s nerves and effectiveness. With leave or rest camp or hospital-stay an officer could last, usually effectively, for ten months. But after a year, he would be “worse than useless” (157-159). And officers were much more likely to be killed than were the men they commanded. Death or neurasthenia, or both, was inevitable.
Graves uses a very precise tone in his memoir to distance himself from all that. Paul Fussel, an American critic who has focused on war literature, calls Graves a “manic illusionist” (206). We can only guess at the manic state of mind that may have compelled the writing of Goodbye to All That. But the illusionist’s methods are there to see, even if subtle. Steven Trout says that Graves’s memoir “offered myths (stories that while literally not true, lend a sort of order to experience and arguably achieve a different kind of authenticity) rather than the reconstruction of historical reality” (176). If the memoir is literally therapy for Graves, then it is a “sense of order” and a personal sense of the authenticity of the story that is the point. That Graves used phrases such as “they say” or “was said to have” or “is alleged to have” to make himself seem a reliable narrator of the factual is simply literary device. That, for one short example, he includes the account of machine gunners “removing cartridges from their gunbelts in order to ‘rap out’ a daily exchange of courtesies” with the enemy (which Fussell points out was simply impossible) is an interesting contrast to most of the Great War literature. That Graves attempts to suspend the reader’s disbelief by providing further detail, claiming that the German reply was in “a slower tempo, because our guns were faster than theirs” underlines a very modern and consciously ironic, even devious rhetoric (Fussell, 207; Trout, 180; Graves, 1929, 208-209). But the question, in psychological context, is this: why does Graves need to pretend, to convince himself and his reader that these anecdotes were really part of the trench experience? Why does Graves insist that he knows of one more instance of the Christmas singing truce that happened even after both armies had declared it to be treason? Is Graves rebuilding a reality of the War to make it, in retrospect, more bearable than it in fact was?
One might also ask if Andy Collins in Sergeant Back Again is creating his own version of the Vietnam War. The answer, I believe, is that Collins is creating his own version of himself in his memoir. But we must remember that it is the fictional character Collins whose memoir we are reading, and his act of writing the memoir may be, likely is, continuing the reintegration of his personality. As Philip Beidler notes, some early reviewers of Coleman’s novel felt that
…the attempt to devise various fictive modes of representation—official documentary reports, dramatized renditions of counseling interviews and experiments in group therapy, reconstructions of free-flowing dream-fantasy and harrowed psycho-nightmare—came close to being an unneeded embellishment upon materials that might perhaps have been more powerfully dealt with had they been left as unmediated case history (197).
But readers with such reactions misread the novel, ignoring the premise stated in the last sentence. In the best ironic modern fashion, we are compelled by that last sentence to read the book again and take every variation from straight narrative as evidence of Collins’s growing understanding. For Andy Collins, literature—writing his memoir—is an ongoing cure.
Paul O’Prey, editor of two volumes of Graves’s selected letters, views the writing of Goodbye to All That from another psychological viewpoint. “To a poet still traumatized by the psychological experience of mental and physical horrors to which his poetry had on the whole proved unequal,” Thomas Hardy’s advice to Graves to write “on the old themes in the old ways” was comforting, but Graves quickly renounced this nostalgic and conservative approach, and as we have seen, turned to the advice of Rivers, hoping that advice would make his poetry more therapeutic. But Graves’s direction taken after writing his 1929 memoir was even more dramatic:
The writing of Goodbye to All That, and the associated break with family, friends and literary associates, followed by voluntary exile to a remote corner of Europe, were all parts of another form of death for Graves—a sort of social suicide—which again brought the possibility of resurrection and the refashioning of identity (O’Prey, 41-42).
As proof of this precise intent on Graves’s part, consider the next to last line of the 1929 edition of Goodbye to All That:
I write these words on July 24th, my 34th birthday; another month of review and I will have parted with myself for good (439).
These lines, like many others, were deleted from later editions. But Graves left for Mallorca with Laura Riding immediately after the publication of Goodbye to All That, perhaps hastened by the many threats of lawsuits arising from his memoir, perhaps hastened by his sense that only a complete break could further minimize his neurasthenia, if not cure it altogether.
Indeed, after his self-imposed “exile” to Mallorca, little else was said about Graves’s nerves; doubtless his relationship with the overbearing American poet Laura Riding was not easy on his nervous system, but gradually all references to neurasthenia disappeared, except in references to the past in England. Did poetry cure Graves? Or did his neurasthenia forever affect his poetry?
While the references to neurasthenia seldom appeared after Graves’s exile to Mallorca, one might note that much of the reaction to Graves the artist is sometimes (incorrectly, I think) based on the eccentricities of his life—the odd first marriage and love affairs, the bizarrely masochistic intellectual and artistic submission to Laura Riding and to her theories about poetry and history. It is perhaps unseemly to speculate just how many of these eccentricities might have been the result of ongoing neurasthenia, but I have in fact heard members of Graves’s own family wondering about this very subject, and the last pages of William Graves’s memoir, Wild Olives, concludes with a long series of speculations on this issue.
Graves’s obsession with sounds, for example buzzes as in “The Gnat” and loud voices as in his short story “The Shout,” continued, and this obsession with noise is a common symptom of shell-shock. This obsession focused on common sounds during warfare; interestingly, the obsession with loud noise was an early research interest of W.H.R. Rivers. Eccentricities of dress and hygiene became more pronounced: Graves hated the feel of soap on his skin, and especially after his move to Mallorca, no one could remember him bathing, except for his daily swim in the Mediterranean. His preference for handmade clothing with jewel-like buttons for “native” wear in Mallorca were constantly mentioned by those around him and were sources for letters and essays for Graves.
Other eccentricities include his “analeptic” method of writing historical works, immersing himself so deeply in the historical culture he was writing about that he felt he had temporarily become a citizen of, say, ancient Rome. He even would “absentmindedly” set a place at table for Claudius or Belisarius. Given this concentration and the speed with which Graves produced such an immense body of work, we might have been justified in calling his work habits maniacal in the colloquial sense or even manic in the more specific language of psychiatry.
After Goodbye to All That, Graves wrote about war in oddly diminished ways: he argued that Homer had a satiric purpose which no modern reader but he had ever understood. This allowed Graves, in his translation of The Iliad, The Anger of Achilles, to turn the bloody limb- and head-severing Homeric battles into caricature and humor—just as he had done earlier with the ridiculous scenes of Claudius’s army in Britain.
Graves’s perhaps most consistent eccentricity as a writer was his constant assumption that surface reality and the conclusions of lesser minds are frequently if not always wrong: it was necessary to write The Real David Copperfield to correct the record. The real Nazarene Gospels had to be restored. Everyone was wrong about the trial of William Palmer. The Rubaiyat that everyone knows is not the original one. The many murders of Livia, with her box of poisons, explain nearly all of Roman history between Julius Caesar and Claudius. And so on. Doubtless some of these eccentricities can be understood as part and parcel of the imaginative source of Graves’s huge creativity, but some of his projects, like the 1019-page The Nazarene Gospel Restored, considering both the time and energy Graves lavished on the effort, along with his expectation that the book would remake Protestantism, bordered on delusions of grandeur.
This obsession with an underlying, hidden truth may explain the constant puzzle-solving that marks so many of the critical plot points in Graves’s fiction (as in Antigua, Penny, Puce, for example), and his constant use of iconotropy as an explanation in his scholarship. Iconotropy occurs, Graves says, when a later generation or a conqueror misunderstands or willfully misinterprets the statues or the art of an earlier generation. Was the unpleasant Biblical story of Lot and his daughters based on an iconotropic misunderstanding and reinterpretation of a statue of Isis and Nephthys mourning at the bier of a recumbent ithyphallic statue of Osiris (Graves’s rather grandiose phrasing)—and is there a story to be had there? For Graves, the quotidian world simply cannot be trusted, just as in his immediately post-war work: if not a horror breaking through the calm surface, then it is now a greater truth emerging—one that only Graves can understand and absorb.
After Laura Riding’s departure, Graves had a short period of serenity, but “his sanguinary temperament was shortly to create new conflicts which would make him as crabbed and aggressive as ever” (Day, 146). These new conflicts centered on Graves’s development of the White Goddess theories, a mythography that posits an all-powerful Muse who should be worshipped in poetry and elsewhere. This is the “one story and one story only” that completely takes over Graves’s poetry from about 1950 onward, and which is responsible for a monochromatic monotony of subject matter—even if the poems themselves are “lapidary” in their metrical perfection, as one critic claims and as I would also argue, as well. Almost without exception, the poems Graves wrote thereafter are love poems, written about the poet-lover and his masochistic relationship with the superior female. As Hoffman describes it, “the vocabulary changes over the years from the psychological to the mythographic,” (158) but the poetry is still about the necessity of submitting to love which is sometimes love, and sometimes (since the moon goddess must sacrifice her king/poet/lover annually) horror. The fate of the Muse/Goddess’s lover, the king who must be replaced, is always a maiming or killing. Graves’s idea of love itself became constant stress, constant submission to the authority of the Muse. And Graves perseverated in insisting that the White Goddess was so real that she is here, now.
Is it relevant that Graves moved from his 1916 poem “I Hate the Moon” (because moonlight made night patrols even more dangerous) to worshipping in life and in poetry a Moon Goddess?
Harold Bloom referred to these later poems—and by extension, some aspects of Graves’s life—as “masochistic insistence on the mutual renderings of poet and Muse as being true love” (186).
The most public aspects of his obsession with the Goddess and Muse took the form of Graves’s insistent, serial relationships with younger women, each of whom he was convinced was the Muse at that moment. Perhaps platonic (but seeming not so in the resulting poems), these relationships were sometimes centered on motivating his poetry, but for a man in his 60s, it is remarkable that Graves seemed unconcerned that these obsessive connections, some of which were with teenage girls, were embarrassing for his family and friends, and were causing enormous damage to his reputation. As it became more and more clear that he would write poetry only about the mythographic meaning he found in his attachments to these young women, Graves found himself with fewer and fewer readers. Equally damaging, this withdrawal into a perverse mythology (which some, most notably Randal Jarrell, have described as a perverse individual psychology) gave critics the opportunity to fixate on the details of his biography rather than on his work, early or late.
Michael Kirkham describes Graves’s first period of work as “a time of restless experiment…at the mercy of unceasing emotional stress.” Graves originally tried “merely to escape from conflict into a literary or folk world of pastoral and simplified emotion.” Later poems were “studiously flat, discursive… antiromantic and self-disciplinary…a very large portion of them were external and pedestrian…irresponsibly cynical…too elegantly detached” (4-5). Indeed Kirkham, like Cohen and Day and all the other early critics of Graves, wrestles at length with the question of Graves’s status—is he a major or minor poet? And even Graves’s biographers are, in fact, ambivalent about his poetry. Richard Perceval Graves, after noting that the Claudius novels are still widely read and that Goodbye to All That “remains required reading for all students of the First World War,” seems much less optimistic about all but a few examples of Graves’s poetry:
“It is The White Goddess,” R.P. Graves asserts, “which, alongside a handful of Graves’s poems, will from time to time have to be translated into more modern English, and will carry his name down the centuries into some remote future (513). In the revised edition (1995) of his Graves biography, Martin Seymour-Smith summarizes his view of Graves’s work, adding that it had been obvious to those who “read between the lines” of his 1982 edition, although he suppressed its overt expression: “The view is, in brief, that he wrote most of his best poetry between the years 1920 and (approximately) 1950…” (xii).
Now criticism of Graves’s work becomes more disparaging with every passing year. One might consider a group of reviews and articles that appeared around 1995, the centennial year of Graves’s birth, and a year in which new biographies and new editions of biographies were appearing.
In his review of these biographies, Denis Donoghue begins with the disparaging “Scholars have been blowing on Graves’s embers since he died in 1985” (27). He dismisses Seymour-Smith’s biography as “joyless” because Seymour-Smith recognized that “the poet, the center of it, was tedious.” Donoghue delights in his phrase “nymphological disquiet,” and one finds this near-satiric tone repeated in almost all of the writing about Graves in major newspaper and review outlets. It amounts to little more than gossip and a parading of the reviewer’s assumed moral superiority, but for readers it is near unavoidable.
In a similar review in the Wall Street Journal of October 24, 1995, after opining that “Graves’s reputation has declined” and that “Graves appears to be in danger of being known primarily as the author of the historical novels upon which the hit television series I, Claudius was based,” (D8) the reviewer, Jamie James, cannot resist using the word “gynaecolatry” to describe Graves’s “idolatry” of The White Goddess and her incarnations, Graves’s “personal Muses.”
James Longenbach, a scholar of American poetry, declares Graves a minor poet “who turned out love poems almost by rote” (634).
Yet another example of Graves’s diminishing reputation: in an article in The New Criterion Robert Richman begins admiringly, speaking of Graves’s “extraordinary productivity…on a scale we associate more with the previous century than with our own” and Graves’s “fame as a cranky individualist.” But Richman too goes quickly to the biographical, arguing that this “posture as a rebel” can only be viewed as ironic, lingering over his thesis that Graves “craved guidance” from women, and he repeats some of the “1960-ish” rumors about Graves, hallucinogens, and the “liberated sexual atmosphere” in Deya (1).
Richman’s reading of the later poems is even more critical, questioning Graves’s early post-war decision to suppress his emotions in his poetry:
If Graves had not been so often compelled to be literal—that is, anti-symbolical and anti-metaphorical—he probably would have been freer to take on a wider range of emotional and thematic concerns in his verse (8).
Some poems that succeed are charged with imagery, but “more common is Graves’s literalism, which spoils many of his love poems.”
Richman’s cruel final judgment assumes that these weakness in Graves’s work are caused by his insistence on the importance of the Goddess:
. . .his worship of the Goddess prevented him from securing major status as a poet, largely because it led him to adopt an anti-metaphorical, anti-symbolical stance toward poetry. (He once characterized this in a letter as his habit of discussing things ‘truthfully and factually’). The limited imaginative range of his work—the ‘one story and one story only’ obviously owes everything to her [the Goddess] as well (11).
I would counter Richman’s judgment: in fact all these tendencies Richman notes in Graves’s middle and later poetry had their origins not in the limitations of the White Goddess thesis, but in Graves’s Rivers-derived theories applied to the creation and use of poetry, and in Graves’s need to use poetry to control his own emotions, to attempt a cure of his neurasthenia.
Conclusion
The outline of the slow shift into senility is well known to many modern readers, but Robert Graves’s final ten years are particularly saddening, given his previous energy of intellect and imagination. For those interested in the long term effects of neurasthenia, shell-shock, or post-traumatic stress disorder, it is quite relevant that most of the last words uttered by Robert Graves were about the Great War.
In November 1976, he began reliving [again] his terrifying experiences in the trenches…returned to the horror of shells bursting all around him, of dead and dying comrades, and of patrolling by moonlight through the shattered waste of no-man’s-land (R.P. Graves, 1995, 499).
And more heartbreaking still is his last fixed idea, his personal sense of guilt: Not only was Robert immersed in the muddy battlefields of the Somme, but his conscience troubled him; and in his more lucid moments he lamented that he had murdered many men. [When a visitor]…politely demurred: that’s hardly murder, Graves had answered emphatically in his confident and authoritative voice of thirty years back: “It is, you know” (R.P. Graves, 1995, 500).
For Siegfried Sassoon, his fictionalized memoirs describe what had been a cure for Sassoon and for his character George Sherston: the W.H.R. Rivers “talking cure” followed by the act of recording it in fiction. For Andy Collins, the act of writing his memoir described his recovery, continued his recovery, and symbolized that recovery. For Robert Graves, well, literature had promised a cure, had made living with “neurasthenia” easier, for a while.
John Woodrow Presley, Ph.D.
WORKS CITED
Beidler, Philip D. 2007. American Literature and the Experience of Vietnam. Athens: University of Georgia Press.
Cohen, J.M. 1960. Robert Graves. New York: Grove Press.
Coleman, Charles. 1980. Sergeant Back Again. New York: Harper and Row.
Day, Douglas. 1963. Swifter than Reason: The Poetry and Criticism of Robert Graves. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Eissler, Kurt R. 1986. Freud as an Expert Witness: The Discussion of War Neuroses between Freud and Wagner-Jauregg. Second edition. (Christine Trollope, translator). Madison, CT: International Universities Press.
Fussel, Paul. 1975. The Great War and Modern Memory. London: Oxford University Press.
Graves, Richard Perceval. 1987. Robert Graves: The Assault Heroic. New York: Viking.
Graves, Richard Perceval. 1995. Robert Graves and the White Goddess 1940-1985. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
Graves, Robert. 1920. Country Sentiment. London: Martin Secker.
Graves, Robert. 1929. Goodbye to All That. London: Cape.
Graves, Robert. 1924. The Meaning of Dreams. London: Cecil Palmer.
Graves, Robert. 1922. On English Poetry. New York: Knopf.
Graves, Robert. 1921. The Pier-Glass. London: Martin Secker.
Graves, Robert. 1925. Poetic Unreason. London: Cecil Palmer
Graves, Robert. 1923. Whipperginny. London: Heinemann.
Hoffman, Daniel. 1967. Barbarous Knowledge: Myth in the Poetry of Yeats, Graves, and Muir. New York: Oxford University Press.
James, Jamie. 1995. Review. Wall Street Journal. October 24, 1995. D8.
Jarrell, Randall. 1952. Robert Graves and the White Goddess. Yale Review, 1956, collected in Mary Jarrell, ed. 1999. No Other ook: Selected Essays. New York: HarperCollins Publishers.
Kersnowski, Frank. 2002. The Early Poetry of Robert Graves: The Goddess Beckons. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Kirkham, Michael. 1969. The Poetry of Robert Graves. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kudler, Harold, 2009. Psychiatric Insights. Unpublished manuscript.
Longenbach, James. 1995. Review. The Nation. November 20, 1995. 633-640.
O’Prey. Paul. 1999. Captain Graves’s Postwar Strategies. New Perspectives on Robert Graves. Ed. Patrick J. Quinn. London: Associated University Presses.
Quennell, Peter. 1960. The Sign of the Fish. London: Collins.
Richman, Robert. The poetry of Robert Graves. The New Criterion. October, 1988. 1-12. Accessed online October 11, 2004, at http://www.newcriterion.com/archive/07/oct88/richman.htm (Page numbers in text refer to the online version).
Sassoon, Siegfried. 1930. Memoirs of an Infantry Officer. London: Faber and Faber.
Sassoon, Siegfried. 1936. Sherston’s Progress. London: Faber and Faber.
Seymour, Miranda. 1995. Robert Graves: Life on the Edge. London: Doubleday.
Seymour-Smith, Martin. 1995. Robert Graves: His Life and Work. Revised and extended edition. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
Trout, Steven. 1999. Telling the Truth—Nearly: Robert Graves, Daniel Defoe, and Goodbye to All That. New Perspectives on Robert Graves.
Ed. Patrick J. Quinn. London: Associated University Presses.
Webb, Thomas E.F. 2006. “Dottyville”—Craiglockhart Hospital and shell-shock treatment in the First World War. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, vol 99, 342-346.